I really believe we'll have the [extra] wild card for this year. Clubs really want it. I don't think I've ever seen an issue that the clubs want more than to have the extra wild card. ... It looks to me like we'll have it, because I've told everybody we have to have it. It will be exciting. A one-game playoff and it will start the playoffs in a very exciting manner.The two wild card teams in each league would play a one-game playoff. (If teams tie for first place in a division, they would play a one-game playoff to determine playoff position.) The winner of the wild card playoff would then play the team with the best record in the league. That would likely mean the end of the rule stating that the wild card team cannot play the first place team in its division, regardless of record (Red Sox/Yankees ALDS, anyone?).
Having two wild cards could mean that a third-place team from a particularly strong division could win the World Series.
16 comments:
Argh. Leave it to MLB, they always get it wrong.
Bud, all the teams would love it if every team made the playoffs. Doesn't mean you do it.
(I also don't like how all one-game playoffs have been between teams with identical records, but now you could have one between teams ten games apart.)
I think it kind of sucked a few years back when our final game vs. the Yankees didn't matter because we would have been the WC even if we had won and tied them. So this will fix that.
Jere, at least the game wouldn't be an elimination game -- i.e., you lose, you still have a WC playoff.
I don't hate it. But no more playoff teams than this, for sure.
but now you could have one between teams ten games apart.)
Ten seems like a stretch (maybe you've looked at past years to see what would have happened), but right now we have DS and CS and WS games with teams with potentially vastly different records. (Not one-gamers, though, admittedly.) The stupid Cardinals won the WS with the same record the Red Sox had for 3rd place.
2011 - TB 91 vs BOS 90
2010 - NYY 85 vs BOS 89
2009 - BOS 95 vs TEX 87
2008 - BOS 95 vs NYY 89
2007 - NYY 95 vs winner of DET 88 vs SEA 88
2006 - DET 95 vs CWS 90
Of those 6 years, a third place team was involved 4 times!
And BOS/MFY games for the WC in 2 of 3 years!
you can now reply to a specific comment and have your reply be indented under that comment. so no more copying a bit of someone's post to note who you are talking to.
if your comment is general, then just type in the comment box
Well look at that! Fancy.
I'm not talking about the division one-game playoff (which WOULD be between teams with identical records), I'm talking about the one-game playoff between the two wild card teams, who could have wildly different records, and IS an elimination game.
"(Not one-gamers, though, admittedly.)"
Right--I'm just sayin', no one-game playoff has ever been between teams who didn't have the same record. And I didn't check the past, but the difference could potentially be huge.
Okay, so in 2007, it would have been a one-game playoff to figure out the second WC, and then the winner would play the first WC in another one-game playoff?
How soon after this are there going to be six teams from each league in the post-season? Or eight? Are we going to turn into the NBA and NHL and see the post-season last two months?
To my mind this is such a bad idea for a league that plays 162 games. It de-legitimizes that long haul when a good season can be undone by one bad game. At least in a five game series there is both drama and a sense that the depth of a roster's quality is likely to win out (even if a hot team can clearly win despite a weaker regular season). Now it seems like a much weaker team that has a single, dominant starter is in great shape.
I'll bet a best-of-3, -5 or -7 is as much of a crap shoot as a one-game playoff. Or much more of a roll of the dice than we think it is.
Changed the comment format back - it wasn't as neat as I thought.
Carry on.
2011 - TB 91 vs BOS 90
2010 - NYY 85 vs BOS 89
2009 - BOS 95 vs TEX 87
2008 - BOS 95 vs NYY 89
2007 - NYY 95 vs winner of DET 88 vs SEA 88
2006 - DET 95 vs CWS 90
I get it. The Blue Jays still don't make the playoffs.
Well done, sir.
Post a Comment