Pages

October 29, 2008

Confusion On The Ground

I turned on WS 5 in the fifth inning and sheets of rains were falling. I could not believe the umpires were allowing the game to continue. Tampa Bay scored the tying run in the top of the sixth inning (I'm sure the umps heaved a sigh of relief) and out came the tarp. They could not resume the game last night, so the remainder of Game 5 is now set for tonight.

Reading this SoSH Thread about Bud Selig (as well as the lengthy WS thread starting here), I have to admit that I cannot paint the Used-Car Salesman as the huge idiot I usually do.

Once the game began -- was everyone fooled by a conservative weather forecast? -- Selig followed the rule book. There seems to have been a genuine failure to communicate between Selig, umpires, team officials, managers, players, media, and fans about how the game would be treated if it was delayed/suspended. I will also state that a World Series championship should never be decided by a game that lasts fewer than nine innings.

The Phillies clearly have the advantage for the rest of Game 5. They get to bat first and they get to bat last. Obviously, the game should have been suspended much earlier than it was. But that cannot be undone. And while it would be in violation of the rules, I'm wondering if the best solution is to wipe out what was played of Game 5 and simply start the game over.

182 comments:

  1. Selig said after the game that had the Phillies been ahead 2-1 in the sixth when the tarp went on the field, they would not have been awarded the win, and that the game had to go nine innings (despite what the rule book says).

    A better question to ask: Had Carlos Pena made out instead of tying the game with a single in the top of the sixth, would the umps have let the game go on?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Looking through the rules, there doesn't seem to be any basis for tossing out the score and starting over. The game could've been called after five innings but wasn't -- there's no way to go back now.

    It's a suspended game under 4.11(d)(1) and has to get completed at a future date under 4.12(a)(5)(i). Rule 4.12(d) specifies how suspended games get played (resumed at the exact moment of suspension, with lots of elaboration), and it doesn't permit a do-over.

    If that weren't enough, the note to Rule 4.12 says: Any regulation game called due to weather with the score tied (unless situation outlined in 4.12 (a) (5) (i) prevails) is a tie game and must be replayed in its entirety. Rule 4.12(a)(5)(i) is precisely what applies here, so no replay.

    MLB's mistake was letting the game start at all or letting it progress far enough to become a regulation game under 4.12(b). Once that happened, resuming the game tonight is their only option under the rules.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I don't have a problem resuming the game in the bottom of the 6th. They're going by the rulebook. What might need to change is how this situation is handled in the rulebook.

    In the end it kind of evens out, if you think about it. The Rays get a, what some might call a cheap run, or a fraudulent run, in the top of the 6th as the elements prevented the players from playing to their full natural abilities.

    So they get that run. The game is tied. We resume the game, begin at the bottom of the 6th, and the Phillies, as you said, get to bat first and bat last. Phillies pitchers will throw 3 innings while Tampa will need to throw 4 innings unless Philadelphia makes the bottom of the 9th unnecessary.

    One way or another, tonight will be very, very interesting. A 3.5 inning sprint, all tied up... Don't know who will pitch, don't know who will lead off the inning (pinch-hitter for Hamels)... Can't use David Price immediately because his spot would come up in the 7th...

    Never in World Series history has there been a 3.5 inning (regulation) game. Tonight we'll see one.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Had Carlos Pena made out instead of tying the game with a single in the top of the sixth, would the umps have let the game go on?

    From what Selig stated post-game, he would have told the umpires to continue the game in the bad weather had Pena not singled home Upton to tie the score.

    IMO, the game should never have begun - playing in cold weather is one thing, but playing in cold, WET weather is another. One slip may mean a groin pull or other injury that takes a key player out of the game.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Don't know if you saw this SI article that does a pretty good analysis, along with appropriate praise and blame:

    Unconventional Thinking: MLB makes right decision to cancel

    As for the Used-Car Salesman persona, I liked this part:

    "Selig, in perhaps his most disingenuous moment of the entire press conference, said, "These fans obviously came and bought tickets for a night game, so they deserve to come back and see a night game." Right. Because the scheduling of World Series games is done taking into account, first and foremost, the convenience of the attendees. Because fans have demanded 8:30 local time starts for years. Because when World Series games are played in the Pacific time zone, MLB gives a rip about those people's work schedules."

    The game will be a night game because Fox says so, and for Selig to sit there and say what he said insults everyone's intelligence. Just be honest and say that the game will be a night game because MLB doesn't control its own scheduling. As if the city of Philadelphia, and people holding tickets wouldn't be perfectly happy with a 7 p.m. start. Or 2 p.m. Or 9 a.m. That comment, to me, was the worst thing said last night, and goes a long way toward letting the world know who runs baseball.

    ReplyDelete
  6. MLB's mistake was letting the game start at all or letting it progress far enough to become a regulation game under 4.12(b).

    This was the point I wanted to make.

    I can imagine baseball not being thrilled with the possibility of tossing 3 or 4 innings into the trash can and starting over from stratch -- probably not what they'd like to do with a WS game.

    ReplyDelete
  7. So, the way the current rules are written... a game that is less than five innings old, if the rain stops the game and they can't resume, would be replayed in its entirety at a future date.

    A game that goes longer than five innings where one team is leading another ends as an official game.

    A tie game after five innings is suspended and will resume at a later date.

    Correct? If so, it sounds like that needs to change.

    Of course, a lot of things need to change. Television inflexibility, etc., start times, how the games are broadcast, making the games more available to those without cable, etc. Psst. There still are people who don't have cable television.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Correct?

    Sort've. It's a bit like the infield fly rule: it's supposed to get called a certain way, but it still has to get called that way in order for it to happen. The rules currently permit an indefinite rain delay.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The game that started at 10:00 pm should have been cancelled as well.

    I heard both teams were asked before the game what they wanted to do and they both said to start it......

    For some reason 3.5 innings won't end till 11:00 pm ....

    World series has turned into a television nightmare.....games should start at 7:00 no reason to start any later,besides ratings, its a joke....

    ReplyDelete
  10. Do they still stop serving beer after the 7th tonight?

    ReplyDelete
  11. This is cool. No matter how it got here... This game is cool.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Balfour's warming up... So is Howell.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Sut and OB on the international feed say this is "a sprint to the finish" -- then Sut says it'll be "a fine ending to the 2008 season".

    Ummmm, Sut, this is not Game 7.

    ReplyDelete
  14. and with that i tune in the buffalo feed with faux.

    ReplyDelete
  15. TBR: 000 101 xxx - 2 5 0
    PHI: 200 00x xxx - 2 4 1

    ReplyDelete
  16. Looks like Price is up now... Not surprising.

    ReplyDelete
  17. better:

    TBR: 000 101 ... - 2 5 0
    PHI: 200 00. ... - 2 4 1

    ReplyDelete
  18. it's weird to watch this as carefully as i am -- and not be scoring.

    ReplyDelete
  19. It's funny... No national anthem, but they'll probably do GBA In... One inning.

    ReplyDelete
  20. It's funny... No national anthem

    YAY!

    ReplyDelete
  21. alright, suspended game game thread!

    ReplyDelete
  22. i have been absent from media - is this the first WS game to be stopped and started on another day?

    the phils could play for about an hour, win, and celebrate ... bizarre

    ReplyDelete
  23. alright, suspended game game thread!

    Yay! A game thread!

    And a Jenkins double!

    ReplyDelete
  24. i have been absent from media - is this the first WS game to be stopped and started on another day?

    This is the first suspended World Series game ever.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Allan, yes - in fact, I'm pretty sure this is the first game that was ever interrupted at all once it started.

    ReplyDelete
  26. How've things been in Chez L-Sock and the GTA, Allan?

    Iwamura drops it! Phillies take the lead!

    ReplyDelete
  27. I'm curious to know the answer to JoaT's beer question above.

    How bizarre would it be if the game stays tied and they end up playing 9 innings tonight after all?

    [Iwamura drops ball]

    er.... well, it could still happen!

    ReplyDelete
  28. And Ball-four is gone. Howell to the rescue.

    ReplyDelete
  29. It would have been cool also, if they stayed tied deep into extra innings and it ended up being the length of a regular game.

    ReplyDelete
  30. pretty quiet here. was in the city using some birthday book store gift certs today. L is out.

    we actually had some light snow flurries this morning! and when i parked the car in toronto, some cars in the lot had snow on them. must have been from further north.

    ReplyDelete
  31. i mean ball four is not pleased.

    we'll see about howell

    ReplyDelete
  32. So Balfour goes an inning and a third and gives up a run.

    ReplyDelete
  33. We had the tiniest, finest snow flurries this evening. I go outside and feel one on my face and thought wait a minute... this isn't your run-of-the-mill rain drop.

    ReplyDelete
  34. NW New Jersey (not where I am) had a few inches of snow yesterday - lots of downed trees and power outages.

    Speaking of weather, I was at Game 3 on Saturday (I'd signed up for the lottery to buy tickets on the Phillies' site a few weeks ago) -- not pleasant! But an exciting game, although I think I'm more excited about having seen it now than I was at the time.

    ReplyDelete
  35. McCarver said the Rays have been "penalized" because they're playing in a national league park.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Amazing how some locations in western New York have already received well over a foot of snow. This past storm system and lake effect snow. That'd be so weird to have snow every day pretty much.

    ReplyDelete
  37. lame rays allowing a SB on a 136 play

    ReplyDelete
  38. Thus endeth perhaps the most anticipated and famous bottom half of the 6th inning in history.

    ReplyDelete
  39. phooey - seeing political ads during the buffalo commercials. one anti-obama and some local one. (i'm told obama is not ready for the white house yet (though apparently palin is)).

    ReplyDelete
  40. Hamels in line for the W, by the way. Still able to be the only pitcher in history to go 5-0 in the postseason.

    ReplyDelete
  41. (i'm told obama is not ready for the white house yet (though apparently palin is)).

    Obama's $3 million half-hour advertisement/infomercial ran before the game. It was very, very well done, for an "infomercial". Looked like one of those high-budget documentaries.


    Rocco ties the game with a dong!

    ReplyDelete
  42. Nope. No win for Hamels now. Couple minutes after I said it.

    ReplyDelete
  43. i was thinking about a hinske dong when rocco swung

    ReplyDelete
  44. Price warming quickly now.

    Allan, who would you like to see win tonight?

    ReplyDelete
  45. i was thinking about a hinske dong when rocco swung

    Intersting, throwing Howell up there to bunt.

    ReplyDelete
  46. In this situation Howell will actually execute the bunt. Those things happen in the world series.

    ReplyDelete
  47. i don't really care, but i guess i now want tampa to win (tonight anyway)!

    ReplyDelete
  48. So now Madson's gone and it's Romero to the rescue.

    ReplyDelete
  49. well, we'll have no shortage of moves/strategy tonight!

    ReplyDelete
  50. i don't really care, but i guess i now want tampa to win (tonight anyway)!

    I think it'd be cool for the Phillies to do what the Rays did to us. Rays win tonight. Go back to the Trop, win Game 6, then Philly comes back and wins Game 7.

    As far as it goes right now, I'm up for anything. I still don't want the Rays to win the Series, though.

    ReplyDelete
  51. redsock you aren't watching the international feed on sportsnet?

    ReplyDelete
  52. fyi re playing 9 tonight:
    longest WS game by innings is 14 (red sox and ruth beat brooklyn in game 2, 1916).

    ReplyDelete
  53. no, watching fox on a buffalo station. i am in a no-sut zone!

    ReplyDelete
  54. Ahh, no idea who they were but it sounded more soothing than buck/mccarver.

    And the Fox camera angle is (well, was when i saw it - might have been in tampa) god awful

    ReplyDelete
  55. wow -- daring shit from bartlett -- and close

    ReplyDelete
  56. And the Fox camera angle is (well, was when i saw it - might have been in tampa) god awful

    They're back to a more normal camera angle in Philadelphia. But if this goes back to the Trop, rest assured that assward camera angle will be back.

    ReplyDelete
  57. But Bartlett had some big balls for trying to score from second on that.

    ReplyDelete
  58. TB has to hold them...probably will get shut down by lidge for two, then might have a chance against the lesser half of Philly's 'pen. If it gets to that point we may see Moyer or Myers.

    I don't care who wins, I just want there to be 8 or more runs so I win the over/under I bet on on monday =)

    ReplyDelete
  59. Bartlett wasn't even running that hard!

    ReplyDelete
  60. But Bartlett had some big balls for trying to score from second on that.

    They showed the replay, Zimmer was at 3b waving him in!

    ReplyDelete
  61. That's a good thing about the Red Sox not in the World Series... You can bet objectively with people.

    ReplyDelete
  62. McCarver refers to J.C. Romero as J.C. Martin, who hasn't played since 1972.

    Man, everyone's smacking the ball around tonight!

    ReplyDelete
  63. So now Howell's gone. Brad Chadford to the rescue.

    ReplyDelete
  64. looked like that hit the wall beyond the state farm sign, seemed like a dong, i guess not.

    ReplyDelete
  65. Scott Eyre and Chad Durbin warming for Philadelphia.

    ReplyDelete
  66. Victorino hit a grand slam in Game 2 of the ALDS. He's bunting right now.

    ReplyDelete
  67. McCarver says he doesn't think he should bunt. He kept trying to bunt... Gets a 1-2 count, bunt is off, he grounds out to second to get Bruntlett to third. Buck lauding the at-bat now.

    ReplyDelete
  68. felix single up middle, with infield in, 4-3 phils.

    ReplyDelete
  69. Derek Jeter is sitting in his living room watching that play thinking man... Wish I could do that.

    Romero was allowed to hit... Dobbs goes back to the bench. Very interesting strategy in general, for sure.

    ReplyDelete
  70. Wow, a game thread and I didn't even know! Cool!

    As much as I am indifferent with respect to who wins the Series, I think it would be wrong for the Phillies to win the Series based on a 3 and half inning game where they get 3 more outs than the other team. I hope the Rays win this one.

    ReplyDelete
  71. There was no GBA, by the way.

    ReplyDelete
  72. There was no GBA, by the way.

    No anthem. No GBA.

    This is my favorite game of all time.

    ReplyDelete
  73. Did Buck really say Crawford was 0-3 in this game before he got that hit? Does his performance on Monday really have anything to do with today? (Apparently not.)

    ReplyDelete
  74. Aybar takes over for Pena at 1st base.

    And Price is in.

    ReplyDelete
  75. C'mon utley....i need my over!

    ReplyDelete
  76. Listening to Phillies radio. Harry Kalas at the mic.

    ReplyDelete
  77. So are you all rooting for the Phillies? Odd to be in a game thread where not everyone is rooting for the same team...

    ReplyDelete
  78. Kalas has a way of making Game 5 of the World Series sound like a regular season game on a lazy summer afternoon.

    ReplyDelete
  79. Ehh, I don't really care. I just bet that it would be 8 or more runs so I want one more run in! And I don't think they'll get it off Lidge.

    Howard - finish this postseason on a high note!

    ReplyDelete
  80. Harry Kalas at the mic.

    That sounds dirty.

    ReplyDelete
  81. So are you all rooting for the Phillies? Odd to be in a game thread where not everyone is rooting for the same team...

    I'm letting things happen. I want the Phillies to win the Series, but I wouldn't mind the Rays taking this to Game 7. How's your late October, Amy? Get any snow out there?

    ReplyDelete
  82. Really, Allan? I thought you had said you wanted the Rays to lose last I checked. Or, like me, do you just want them to win this game so the series continues?

    ReplyDelete
  83. Tim, how much did you have riding on this bet?

    ReplyDelete
  84. 90 feet closer to me winning 10 dollars!

    ReplyDelete
  85. just tonight. i'll see how i feel about game 6 when game 6 starts.

    ReplyDelete
  86. We had a few flurries, Ish, but just a momentary thing. Damn cold, though. How are things in Maine? Toronto? Any snow up north?

    ReplyDelete
  87. $8.50

    big money for me!

    ehh I won 20 on the Bs last night so I'm good.

    And this concludes my brief history of sports betting. That isn't proline.

    ReplyDelete
  88. OK, three more outs, and if no scoring, no more baseball til spring. :(

    ReplyDelete
  89. Amy, the lightest of flurries. To the point where I had to decide whether it was actually snow or not. Happened this evening.

    ReplyDelete
  90. Lidge v

    Longoria
    Navarro
    Baldelli
    (Bartlett)

    ReplyDelete
  91. My car was coated in a layer of flurries, and windshields were icy. Up here in Waterloo.

    I'm spending a couple days up in Waterloo so I'm not at home with my gloves/ice scraper.

    Luckily I found another, crappier ice scraper in my car. But my hands were chilly after that.

    ReplyDelete
  92. ehh I won 20 on the Bs last night so I'm good.

    You didn't bet they'd win 1-0 did you? That was the first time since, I think 1936, that the Bruins won back-to-back 1-0 games.

    ReplyDelete
  93. I've had to scrape off frost a few times. Nothing else yet. Well, I made my sister do it. I was giving her a ride at 7 AM.

    ReplyDelete
  94. heh no i just bet on the win. (including OT). theres a regulation win category, but i didnt want to be that risky.

    yeah they were good games. but thomas can't stand on his head forever.

    anyway enough about this. we can discuss Bs for the long long winter, after the next 3 outs!

    ReplyDelete
  95. (delayed response)

    I'm rooting for the Rays. But I won't lose any sleep if the Phillies win tonight.

    ReplyDelete
  96. World series being won at home - kick ass.

    ReplyDelete
  97. This has my heart beating a touch faster, interestingly. Finality.

    ReplyDelete
  98. i wont cry if tb loses.

    a good friend of ours from brooklyn (now in london) is a huge phillies fan (we watched joe carter dong in 93 at their apt. good thing they drank (a lot)!)

    ReplyDelete
  99. I love being able to pick up AM radio stations at night from far away.

    ReplyDelete
  100. I will be more sad that baseball is really over than that the Rays lost.

    My Phila. relatives will be happy.

    ReplyDelete
  101. a huge phillies fan (we watched joe carter dong in 93 at their apt.

    Man, that must have been crushing. I can't imagine being so close only to lose on--

    oh, wait, yes I can.

    ReplyDelete
  102. Hinske probably will bat next.

    Nope. Zobrist.

    ReplyDelete
  103. Game going to end at the time of a normal reg season game.

    ReplyDelete
  104. I will be more sad that baseball is really over than that the Rays lost.

    I certainly relate to you there. Definitely.

    ReplyDelete
  105. That joe dong was fucking epic.

    ReplyDelete
  106. Also L was going to college in philly in 1980.

    ReplyDelete
  107. Navarro keeps things alive with a base knock.

    ReplyDelete
  108. that was when she saw a game at the vet -- giving her one more park than me. grrrrrr

    ReplyDelete
  109. So was the game before the joe dong, where "Wild Thing" blew the lead and the jays scored like 6 in the 8th or something.


    ooo shit, navarro on.

    ReplyDelete
  110. rut roh lidge - don't think about losing

    ReplyDelete
  111. Kind of torn with feelings. It doesn't feel like the Rays are just going to finish this one off without scoring again.

    Zobrist up with Fernando Perez running for fat MDC.

    ReplyDelete
  112. Tying run on...maybe the baseball season has some life left?

    ReplyDelete
  113. If they tie it, I hope it goes for awhile.

    ReplyDelete
  114. she was pretty effing fast with the off button on that TV, i'll say that.

    ReplyDelete
  115. Perez steals second... Not surprising.

    ReplyDelete
  116. Perez has my $10 profit in his hands!

    ReplyDelete
  117. i do recall that 15-14 game was totally nuts.

    ReplyDelete
  118. Scoring position!

    Well, Allan, guess you have to get to Philadelphia. Or else go to another park without Laura, which wouldn't seem like fun. Which others have you not yet been to?

    ReplyDelete
  119. she was pretty effing fast with the off button on that TV

    Sounds like me (and probably some others here) a couple of Sundays ago.

    ReplyDelete
  120. Two out.

    Hinske to K for the third.

    ReplyDelete
  121. I want hinske to dong here, as a big FUCK YOU to Toronto fans.

    ReplyDelete
  122. L agrees

    FUCK THE JAYS!!!!!!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  123. This is certainly the way it should end if it does right now. Tying run at second with a perfect postseason hitter at the dish. 1 for 1 with a dong. How can you be more perfect?

    ReplyDelete
  124. Wow, that check swing was way less checky than the Utley one last inning.

    ReplyDelete
  125. Phillies win. FKRs fucked.

    Hinske Ked.

    ReplyDelete
  126. damn - no longer defending champs.

    ReplyDelete
  127. That's it. No more baseball...

    Now I can simply obsess about the damn election...

    See you all around the hot stove!

    ReplyDelete
  128. Phillies win it!

    Fuck you Rays! The Red Sox will NOT face the World Champions 18 times next season!

    ReplyDelete
  129. How many days until Truck Day?

    ReplyDelete
  130. Finally won at home. Good stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  131. FOX showing the reaction of every player.

    ReplyDelete
  132. One nice thing... All the kids can stay up and watch the celebration.

    ReplyDelete
  133. So now... the off-season has fully begun. Only ____ shopping days until Christmas.

    ReplyDelete
  134. "It's amazing, man. Amazing how one year ago the Boston Red Sox cut me loose and this year I'm a world champion."

    J.C. Romero.

    ReplyDelete
  135. That's one guy who I feel very happy for. Struggles in Boston, gets DFA'd, goes to Philadelphia, pitches well, earns a set-up role... and now gets to feel the joy of winning a world series for himself.

    ReplyDelete
  136. All the kids can stay up and watch the celebration

    Good point, ish!

    Maybe Fox will figure out a way to have all elimination/clinching games spread out over two nights like this so that they don't end so late. 'Cause, of course, it's not like starting them earlier is an option.

    Nice to see everyone for a couple of hours, see you during the off-season!

    ReplyDelete
  137. phil said...
    Two out.
    Hinske to K for the third.
    Wed Oct 29, 09:56:00 PM


    No prognostication loving? :)

    ReplyDelete
  138. Watched the first pitch in japan, and the last in Philly. Good year, sucks this isn't our time. But, hey, it was a good ride. We'll be back next year and ready to kick some ass.

    100% Timlin-free! (hopefully)

    ReplyDelete
  139. I think the Phillies fans still had it in them to boo Bud Selig. Hahaha.

    ReplyDelete
  140. Wouldn't romero have gotten an 07 ring because he was part of the team for at least part of the year?

    ReplyDelete
  141. Wouldn't romero have gotten an 07 ring because he was part of the team for at least part of the year?

    Yep. I'm pretty sure he has an '07 ring.

    ReplyDelete
  142. With any luck, the Rays will peak as the late-1990s Spiders and never amount to anything.

    ReplyDelete
  143. I guess there is a fuck you to jays fans of sorts, with Gillick winning the WS.

    ReplyDelete
  144. will any rays champs hats turn up on ebay?

    ReplyDelete
  145. LMAO. Selig: "Cole was 1-0, with a 2.77 earned run average."

    ReplyDelete
  146. Hamels MVP. Double CS-WS mvp, nice.

    ReplyDelete
  147. Anyway sleep time. See you soon, JoS!

    ReplyDelete